Who will the 12 steps Help ?
AA and all 12 step based fellowships will tell you that doing the 12 steps will make everyone better. I say that assertion is false.
I have over a decade of daily experience working (or performing or doing) the 12 step program’s full set of steps. My experience is that my working the twelve steps had screwed me out of a chance to live a full life. However I do know many folks do did not suffer from ‘working the steps’ .
Now asking the question “Who will the 12 steps Help and who will they hurt?” is suggesting that this might be a 50-50 sort of proposition. In my opinion it isn’t that either. I believe the percentages of both who is actually HELPED and who is actually HURT are fairly low.
I believe that the majority of people who ‘work the steps’ are talking a rite of passage which one must finished in order to be accepted as a full member of their 12 step fellowship. But this rite is not going to have anything other than a placebo effect for most people.
If you do not have the traits that people like me have (we will discuss this shortly) then doing the steps will be likely harmless.
So let us get right to it - what sort of people are going to do the steps and get no ill effects?
- people raised to have self confidence will do well. Whether one or both parents raised you, if you were raised to believe in yourself, told you can succeed, given encouragement through out your childhood, you will do ok with the 12 steps
- attractive people will do well. Beautiful women will do better than handsome men but in general the more attractive a person you are, the more likely the 12 steps cannot do you harm
- wealthy people will do well. Also those who will become wealthy via trust funds, inheritances or marriage can also do well and not be adversely affected by the steps
- highly skilled people will do well. Note highly is underlined. And I did not say intelligent. This can be skilled at salesmanship, or in professional athletics or highly skilled in your profession. Which is likely an effect from the first point in the list. But for argument’s sake, if you are a highly skilled person without any of the other traits listed here, the steps will likely not produce bad effects for you.
OK not exactly the map to the hidden treasure there huh? Yeah, well I am glad you think that, because that makes my point even easier to understand. ANY one of the above traits will allow you to succeed in AA. Own the first trait or any 2 and you cant help but succeed.
The steps wont make one bit of difference in the formula of your success. If you don’t drink or use and one or more of the above traits belong to you, you are going to do great. Or better phrased, the twelve steps will not do you any harm.
In a nutshell, if the above describes you, and you quit drinking and using then you will succeed.
And if you are in AA and doing the work of the 12 steps, both the people around you and you yourself will give all the credit to the steps for your success.
Simple right?
OK, so who is going to get a royal screwing by believing in the Twelve Steps? stay tuned that posting will be here in the next 12 hours.
Â
Harry A.
3 Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
Only registered users can login and comment
Click here to Login
Click here to register
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>
March 16th, 2006 @ 11:20 pm
There are some aspects of what you say that are true. What I’d say is that they *raise the possibility* of being helped.
I’ve seen people who were indeed hopeless and really worthless who’s lives were greatly improved when they quit being drunk, and AA helped in that.
I’ve seen people who were rich and pretty successful, and watched them turn into wretches.
More generally, the majority of people who believe in the concepts of the 12 steps end up having some transformation of personality. If they’re wise about it, they use what works, and don’t try to force themselves into the concepts that don’t work for them. That’s the most common problem that I see - the despair of not being the “perfect” stepper, which is sad. It reminds me that “Good enough, by definition, is good enough”.
March 17th, 2006 @ 10:53 am
Yes Eric I can agree with you that getting Sober in AA can and does help those in the grips of alcoholism. In fact in the “clear up” post I wrote exactly that.
And again, allow me to make clear two points:
1. I agree the steps DO MAKE personality changes
2. It is not for US to say who was helped by the steps. As with the ‘who is an alcoholic’ rule, only the person themselves can claim that for sure - we CANNOT say who the twelve steps “have helped”. Only they themselves can state they were helped.
My personality has changed from working the steps. I went from the happy go lucky fun guy I was through all thru my drinking and using (cept for that last year) to an increasingly unhappy and angry man. Eric, just go Ask Louie Fatch who knew me from age 20; he’ll tell ya about Harry in those years.
March 17th, 2006 @ 10:52 pm
Hi Harry - How the heck is Fatch doing nowadays anyway? Have those adolescent students driven him back to drinking yet? LOL
-e-